The complete guide to making good money from your garage sale

So you’re planning on having a massive declutter of your home and you want to make money from it by having a garage sale. Do you know the best way to ensure you make the MOST money from the sale?

Well, I do.

So here is my complete guide to making money from taking clutter control action.

This post may contain affiliate links.Privacy Policy. Follow us on PINTEREST

These are the garage sale tips that will not only inspire you to declutter but have you banking the most cash from it.

Decluttering and making money are a great combination!

What could be better than decluttering and actually making money from your clutter?

Not only will your home feel lovely and clutter-free you will also have more cash in your bank account. Win win!

But there is an art to selling your stuff.

You need to be smart and sell different household items and other stuff like kids toys and clothes in different ways to make sure you make the most money and don’t waste your time. 

Who knows, if you get good at it, you could turn selling your clutter into a business by graduating to finding stuff in thrift stores to flip for profit.

On the other hand, sometimes it is better to declutter and donate or give away rather than try and make money. This guide will help you make those decisions.

Read on to find out the best household items to sell if you want to make good money.

stop hoarding stuff you never use and don’t need!

One of the biggest issues that stops many of us from decluttering is coming across something that is really good quality and still has lots of use left in it. We pick it up, look it over and then put it back “just in case”. 

But often that item just sits gathering dust or taking up space for more months when instead it could be sold to make some extra cash. 

It took me a while to realise just how much money I could make from selling stuff my family and I no longer wanted or needed.

Ultimately, the incentive of being able to save money towards our next family vacation or just simply to help out with the cost of living spurs me on to declutter and sell what I can on a regular basis. 

After several years of successfully selling our family’s unwanted stuff I have become something of an expert on the best way to do so and make good money.

I’ve also learnt what is best to simply donate or give away. 

Items That Typically Sell Well at Garage Sales

First up, to get you inspired, here’s a quick look list of types of household items and stuff you own that you could look at selling.

Knowing what typically sells well helps you focus your efforts and pricing strategy (and more on pricing strategy later).

These are the main categories of items that tend to sell easily and can sell for good money.

Household Items

• Kitchen gadgets and small appliances (toasters, blenders, coffee makers)
• Kitchenware (pots, pans, utensils, dishes)
• Gardening tools and equipment
• DIY tools (especially hand tools)
• Lamps and lighting fixtures
• Picture frames
• Decorative items
• Curtains and rugs
• Storage containers

Furniture

• Small furniture pieces (end tables, coffee tables, bookshelves)
• Dining chairs
• Outdoor furniture
• Children’s furniture

Children’s Items

• Kids toys (especially if complete and in good condition)
• Lego sets
• Kids bikes and scooters
• Baby gear (high chairs, strollers, playpens)
• Children’s books
• Board games and puzzles

Clothing and Accessories

• Children’s clothing (especially in good condition)
• Seasonal clothing
• Costume jewelry
• Handbags
• Shoes in good condition

Entertainment

• DVDs and Blu-rays
• CDs
• Books (especially paperbacks and children’s books)
• Video games
• Vinyl records (these can be surprisingly popular)

Sporting Goods

• Bicycles
• Camping gear
• Exercise equipment (smaller items like weights, yoga mats)
• Sports equipment (baseball gloves, tennis rackets, golf clubs)

Miscellaneous

• Holiday decorations
• Craft supplies
• Pet accessories
• Collectibles (if priced appropriately)

How to make your garage sale really motor!

Get the Necessary Permissions

First things first! Make sure you’re following local regulations before you start publicising your sale.

There’s no point making money if it ends up going towards paying a fine!

Things to bear in mind include:

• Check if your neighbourhood or homeowners’ association has rules about garage sales
• Some towns require permits for garage sales—check with your local council
• If you live on a private road, ensure you have permission to direct traffic there

Make sure you hit the sweetspot with the timing of your sale. There’s no point hauling all your stuff out for sale unless you’re going to make maximum bucks!

Build it and they (won’t) come (unless you tell them about it)

Even the best-organised sale needs customers. Here’s how to spread the word effectively:

Signs That Work

• Make bold, readable signs with large letters
• Include your address, date, and time
• Use arrows pointing toward your sale
• Waterproof your signs in case of rain
• Place signs at major intersections and turning points

Online Advertising

• Post on local Facebook groups and Nextdoor
• List your sale on Craigslist and garage sale apps
• Include photos of your best items in online listings
• Mention specific high-interest items (Lego, baby gear, tools)

Neighbourhood Promotion

• Tell your neighbours—they often become customers
• Send an email or WhatsApp to your local friends
• Consider collaborating with neighbours for a multi-family sale

It’s In The Timing

Now, here’s a few thoughts about timing your sale right.

Think seasonally

Spring and early autumn are both great times of the year to hold a garage sale.

Not only because of the weather conditions (not too hot, not too cold) but they are also seasons of transition, so people are often in more of a buying mood.

Which day?

Weekends are your best bet – Saturday and Sunday mornings typically draw the biggest crowds.

Start Early

Serious buyers often arrive first thing, sometimes even ahead of the official start time, to try and bag the best stuff. So grin and bear an early start in the name of making maximum cash!

Just make sure you’ve had your morning coffee so you can negotiate well with hardened buyers!!

Other things to bear in mind are to avoid major holiday weekends and to double check local events listings. Your garage sale might be good, but is it likely to be SO GOOD that it beats the local festival or fair?

Make like a shop owner

Having the right “shop” supplies makes the day run so much more smoothly.

Here are a few suggestions:

• Tables and display surfaces
• Clothes rack or clothesline for hanging items
• Calculator, cash box, and plenty of change (coins and small bills) OR payment App.
• Pricing stickers or labels
• Bags and newspaper for wrapping fragile items
• Extension cords for testing electronic items
• Measuring tape for furniture buyers
• Hand sanitiser and wipes
• Refreshments for yourself and helpers

Now we’ve got all the set up done and dusted, here’s a few thoughts on actually pricing your stuff.

Pricing Strategies That Work

The right pricing can make the difference between items sitting all day and them flying off your tables.

Here are a few trusty guidelines to help you decide how to price stuff:

The 10-30% rule

Let’s face it, most of us don’t go to garage sales to pay top dollar! So the rule of thumb is that most garage sale items should be priced at 10-30% of their original value.

Keep the numbers rounded

Even if you are using a payment App, keeping the numbers to $10 or $15 etc rather than $9.95 keeps buyers happy.

It also saves you from fiddling around trying to find coins when you could be making the next sale!

Be realistic

Heartbreaking as it might be to see a fancy kitchen gadget (that you’ve barely used, hence the selling…) go for a song, the reality is that it won’t go at all unless you price it realistically.

Smart Pricing Hacks

Just as aside, here are a few little pricing hacks that will help make life easier for you and your buyers. (And making life easy for your buyers leads to more sales!).

• Use different coloured stickers to indicate different price points
• Create signs for sections: “Everything on this table $1”
• Have a “free box” for items not worth pricing but still usable (the goodwill gesture can lead to reciprocal goodwill in the form of buying something!)
• Consider dropping prices in the final hour—announce a “half-price” time. This is good for making last minute cash but also helps minimise clearing up afterwards!

Setting Up for Success

The way you arrange your sale can dramatically impact your results.

Here’s a few things to consider:

• Position high-interest items near the street to draw people in
• Group similar items together (all kitchen items in one area, toys in another)
• Place a table near the entrance for a cashier station (and also so you can keep an eye on people not making off with stuff they haven’t paid for!)
• Make sure there’s enough space for people to move around comfortably
• Consider your garden layout, create a natural flow for buyers to move around the sale

Display Strategies

You know how delightful it is when you walk into a well laid out store? Well, there’s a reason for them doing that.

A well laid out store means that buyers can easily find what they are looking for and are encouraged to buy stuff!

So here’s a few tips on how to make like an upscale store owner:

• Hang clothes instead of folding them
• Use tables rather than placing items on the ground
• Clean everything—dirty items sell for less
• Remove personal photos from frames

Oh and a final tip for electrical goods…

Test all electronic items and mark them as “working” so the buyer is in no doubt.

Sale Day Tactics

Selling in person doesn’t come naturally to all of us, in fact it can feel downright awkward if you aren’t used to doing it or are something or an introvert.

So here’s a few useful tips on how to handle buyers and browsers.

Meet And greet

Greet everyone who arrives so they know that you know they are there! But don’t hover. Once you’ve said hi, let potential buyers have space to browse, noone likes to feel pressured into buying.

Know your early bird strategy

Be prepared for early birds by deciding your sales policy in advance. This way they can’t corner you into selling stuff at super low prices that you aren’t comfortable with.

Be Alert (Or have someone else do it)

It really does pay to have a helper watch for theft while you’re busy with customers. It’s sad but true that there are people in this world who, for one reason or another, will try and steal from you.

Negotiation Tactics

Know this: You won’t sell everything at the price on the ticket. So, build in some wiggle room to your pricing.

As long as you know the lowest price you are willing to sell an item for, you can’t have sellers regret.

It pays to be more firm earlier on during the sale. You can always be more flexible towards the end, when you can take a call on whether you’d rather hang onto something just get it sold.

Oh and always remember, you don’t have to sell an item if you aren’t comfortable doing so. It’s your sale and your stuff, so you get to make that call.

Kid-wrangling

Now, depending on your neighbourhood and the type of stuff you are selling, you might find that buyers come with their kids in tow.

Cute and lovely as other people’s kids are (!!) it is well worth providing a diversion to keep them entertained.

This is two-fold… the parents can focus on buying and you can be sure the kids won’t cause a nuisance (not saying that kids always do, but… )

So, consider setting up a play area. If you have older kids, ask them to be childcare support through the sale.

You could even go the extra mile and have snacks and juice on hand.

In fact, how about getting your older kids to set up a refreshment stand and they can make some money too?!

After Sale Care (for youself!)

And what about when the sale is over, what then?! Here are a few closing thoughts to help you wrap up…

Dealing with what’s left

Believe me, it pays to have a plan ahead of time on what to do with the stuff that’s left.

Here are some options to consider:

• Schedule a charity pickup for right after the sale
• Take quality clothing to thrift shops
• List more expensive unsold items online (but set yourself a timeframe for doing so, so they don’t just sit there)
• Put up a “free” kerb sign for remaining items (ensuring you don’t fall foul of any neighbourhood laws)

And that’s a wrap… hopefully by this point your sale has made you a nice chunk of cash.

I hope you’ve found this guide useful. And remember, a successful garage sale doesn’t just happen, it’s created through careful planning, smart pricing, and effective promotion.

With these useful tips, you’ll not only clear your clutter but might be surprised by how much money you make in the process.

Pin to save: