Reselling Thrift Store Finds: The Beginner Friendly Guide

ByLuci McQuitty Hindmarsh Last updated:
Pin

Reselling thrift store finds is one of the easiest side hustles to start as a busy mom. You can begin with a tiny budget, fit it around school runs and your day job, then grow at your own pace.

The resale market keeps growing as more of us choose secondhand for style, value and sustainability. That is really good news if you love a bargain and have a decent eye for what people will buy.

In this guide I am going to show you how to get started reselling thrift store finds, how to choose what to buy, where to sell it and how to keep it fun rather than stressful.

This post may contain affiliate links.Privacy Policy. Follow us on PINTEREST

You do not need a business degree. You just need curiosity, a phone with a camera and a willingness to learn as you go.

What does reselling thrift store finds actually mean?

At its simplest, reselling thrift store finds means you:

  • Buy secondhand items cheaply from thrift stores, charity shops, car boot sales and yard sales
  • Clean, photograph and list those items on online marketplaces
  • Sell them for more than you paid and keep the profit after fees and postage

Some people call it thrift flipping, recommerce or reselling. The idea is the same. You are turning your eye for a good find into extra income.

Is reselling thrift store finds worth it?

Short answer, yes, if you treat it like a small business not a lottery ticket.

Here is why it is a strong side hustle right now:

  • More shoppers are happy to buy secondhand, especially for clothing, homeware and tech
  • Platforms like Vinted, Depop, Poshmark and eBay make it simple to list from your phone
  • You can start with clutter from your own home so you are not dipping into the family budget

If you have not sold anything before, start by selling things you already own. My post on easy ways to sell clutter walks you through this step and can give you a little pot of money to invest in your first thrift store finds.

You will have a mix of small profits, a few flops and the odd big win. The magic is in repeating the small wins consistently.

Step by step: how to start reselling thrift store finds

1. Pick a simple niche to start with

Instead of buying random things, pick one or two categories you feel confident about. For example:

  • Women’s high street fashion and handbags
  • Kids’ clothes and baby gear
  • Vintage denim and sportswear
  • Toys and games, especially LEGO and branded sets

Sticking to a small niche at the beginning makes it much easier to research prices and spot deals quickly.

2. Research what actually sells

Before you head out to the thrift store, do a bit of detective work on the main marketplaces.

Look up your chosen category on:

Use the filters to show items that have sold, not just what is currently listed. This shows you what buyers are actually paying, not what sellers hope to get.

You are trying to answer two questions:

  1. Is there a steady market for this type of item
  2. Can I realistically make a profit after buying, fees and postage

If the answer is yes to both, you are good to go. If not, tweak your niche before you spend any money.

3. Set a tiny starter budget

Treat your first month as a test. Decide how much you are willing to invest, then stick to it.

  • Choose a small amount you can afford to lose if nothing sells
  • Spread that across several items, not one big risky buy
  • When things sell, reinvest part of the profit into more inventory

If you are not used to budgeting, have a look at my post on how to create a family budget. It will help you work out a realistic amount to play with.

This is how you grow without raiding the grocery budget. Once you see regular sales, you can slowly increase your buying budget.

4. Plan your sourcing trips

Think of this step as your inventory hunt.

Start close to home and build a little route of places you can visit regularly without spending a fortune on petrol or public transport:

  • Local thrift stores and charity shops
  • Church sales and school jumble sales
  • Car boot sales, yard sales and estate sales

Do not only visit the obvious high street locations. The best finds often hide in smaller shops, side streets and places in more affluent areas where donations are higher quality.

Be friendly with staff and regular sellers. Over time they may tip you off when items in your niche come in.

Take reusable bags and use the notes app on your phone so you can jot down brands and categories to research later.

How to hunt for profitable thrift store finds

5. Do not just glance, really dig

Resellers rarely find the good stuff by standing in the doorway. You need to rummage.

  • Look high and low, not just at eye level
  • Check end of rails and trolleys waiting to be put out
  • Scan sections where things get put back in the wrong place

It is very common to find a great women’s sweatshirt in the men’s section or a branded kids’ item mixed in with baby basics.

Give yourself time in each store. A quick five minute skim will miss most of the gems.

6. Prioritise brands and styles that move fast

Brand names are not everything, but they help, especially when you are learning.

Look for:

  • Popular high street brands in good condition
  • Sporty styles, sneakers and athleisure that teens and Gen Z love
  • Niche or cult brands that have loyal followings

You do not need to chase only luxury names like Louis Vuitton. Mid market brands in great condition can sell very well, especially in current styles.

7. Watch for unique and on trend pieces

Alongside known brands, keep an eye out for pieces that feel special or very now.

Think about:

  • Colours and cuts you see all over Instagram or TikTok
  • Y2K inspired items, retro sportswear and vintage denim
  • Interesting prints or details that stand out in a listing photo

If your gut says someone will love this, do a quick price check on your phone. If there are similar items selling for a decent price, it could be a good buy.

8. Learn to spot rare finds and collectables

You will not hit a jackpot every time, but you can train your eye for special items.

  • Limited edition collaborations between brands and designers or celebrities
  • Older sports shirts and jackets
  • First edition books and interesting non fiction
  • Vintage cameras and retro tech that is popular again

When you find something that seems unusual, search for it online. If you cannot see many for sale and the few you find are listed high, you may have uncovered real treasure.

For more ideas, take a look at my list of items that sell well to make extra money. You can use it alongside this guide when you are out hunting for inventory.

Always buy with condition in mind

9. Only buy items in saleable condition

No matter how good the brand, damaged pieces are harder to sell and bring in less money.

Before you buy, always check:

  • Fabric for stains, holes and heavy fading
  • Zips, fastenings and seams
  • Sizing labels, especially on vintage clothing
  • Electrical items for obvious damage

Some wear can be part of the charm, especially on vintage denim and furniture. What matters is that you can describe it honestly and still feel good about the price.

10. When upcycling makes sense

You can do well buying items that need a little love if you are genuinely happy to clean, mend or repaint and the time and materials will still leave you with a decent profit.

If an item will take you days to fix and only bring in a few extra pounds, it is usually better to leave it on the shelf.

How to price and where to resell your thrift store finds

11. Build a simple pricing strategy

Your pricing will improve with practice, so think of it as an experiment.

Start with this:

  • Check sold listings for similar items on your chosen platform
  • Price in the same range or a touch higher if your item is in better condition
  • Factor in selling fees and postage before you buy

You can also test both fixed prices and auctions if you use eBay. Track what works best for your niche and repeat it.

12. Choose the best places to sell

You do not need to be everywhere. Pick one or two platforms that fit your niche and your location, then branch out later.

Here are some of the best online marketplaces to start selling thrift for a profit:

Poshmark (US): Great for selling high street brands. Like Vinted, you only receive payment once the buyer has received and accepted the item. Here is the guide to starting selling on Poshmark.

MusicMagpie (UK)/Decluttr (US): Great for selling tech, DVDs, CDs and games. Here is the guide to starting selling on MusicMagpie. Here is the guide for starting selling on Decluttr.

Vinted: A great place for selling high street brands. Listings are free on Vinted. You only get paid once your buyer receives the item and confirms they are happy. Here is the guide to starting selling on Vinted.

Depop: The Gen Z favourite. There are no listing fees, but a 10% commission is charged on all sales. Here is the guide to starting selling on Depop.

eBay: You can start off selling as an individual. You could choose to progress to opening an eBay store once you are more established. Here is the guide to starting selling on eBay, and here is the guide to setting up an eBay store.

Etsy: It is free to open an Etsy store, though, as with eBay, there are listing fees, transaction fees and payment processing fees. Here is the guide to opening a store on Etsy.

Many people also have success selling through Mercari, Facebook Marketplace and Instagram. You can also register for a shop on TikTok.

Go to my post on selling clutter to make money for a more in depth overview of the main places to sell stuff online.

One thing I would recommend steering clear of at the beginning is setting up your own website to sell thrift online. While making good money via your website is possible, it takes a lot of hard work to establish a site and bring regular traffic to it.

Using online auction and sales platforms means that, to varying degrees, they do a lot of the hard marketing work for you.

That said, if you know your way around social media, you can always use your social media channels to promote your products and drive buyers to wherever you are selling.

Find your niche and build a recognisable brand

13. Narrow in on what is working

After a few months of reselling thrift store finds you will notice:

  • Certain categories that always sell quickly
  • Price points that feel easy for buyers to say yes to
  • Items that sit for ages and are not worth the effort

Lean into what sells well and what you enjoy sourcing. That combination is your niche.

It is fine if lots of other people are doing something similar. Your eye, your style and your way of presenting items will set you apart.

14. Create a simple brand buyers remember

You do not need a fancy logo, but you do need consistency.

Things that build trust:

  • A clear, memorable shop name that you use across platforms
  • Clean, bright photos taken in the same spot or background
  • Honest, friendly descriptions that mention flaws and measurements
  • Fast, polite replies to messages

Think of your brand as the feeling people get when they browse your shop. You want them to think this seller is organised and trustworthy.

Customer service that brings repeat buyers

15. Make it very easy to buy from you

Customer service is everything, especially in a world full of reviews.

Focus on:

  • Clear pricing and shipping information in your listings
  • A straightforward returns policy that you actually follow
  • Packing items carefully so they arrive in the same condition they left you

If you make a mistake, own it quickly and fix it. Refunds on the odd error are much cheaper than a damaged reputation.

Happy buyers come back again and again, which makes reselling thrift store finds much more rewarding.

Use social media to show off your thrift flips

You do not have to dance on TikTok to resell successfully, but social media can help you reach more buyers and build your brand.

Here are easy ways to use it:

  • Share quick before and after photos of your best flips
  • Post new in items and let followers know where they are listed
  • Use built in tools like Depop and Vinted social feeds to boost visibility

Many of the most successful thrifters have TikTok and Instagram accounts. Take a look at @Beckysbazaar. Becky Chorlton runs a successful thrifting business in the UK and has grown her TikTok account to over 100,000 followers and has over 50,000 followers on Instagram. Becky has stores on eBay, Depop and Vinted.

Real life reselling thrift store finds success stories

If you need proof that this can grow beyond a few bits on eBay, there are plenty of resellers who have built impressive incomes from thrift store finds and yard sale bargains.

23 thrift store items that are often worth reselling

Here is a starter list of pieces that often flip well when you buy carefully.

  • Designer clothes, handbags and shoes
  • High end branded clothes, handbags and shoes
  • Mid market branded clothes, handbags and shoes
  • Vintage denim, especially jeans and jackets
  • Vintage trainers and sneakers
  • Maternity clothes
  • Toys, particularly collectables (LEGO is huge)
  • Vintage board games
  • Sports memorabilia
  • Sports equipment
  • Hobby equipment such as photography, fishing or bird watching gear
  • Camera equipment, including retro cameras
  • Furniture
  • Books, especially first editions and interesting non fiction
  • Textbooks
  • Vinyl records
  • CDs and DVDs
  • Video games
  • Old but working technology
  • Vintage ornaments
  • Vintage tableware and glassware
  • Home decor
  • Baby gear that still meets safety standards

Use this list together with sold listings on your chosen platform. That is how you find the sweet spot between fun to find and good money maker.

Is reselling thrift store finds right for you?

Reselling thrift store finds is not magic money, but it is one of the most flexible, family friendly side hustles out there.

You can start with clutter from your own home, a couple of lunchtime trips to your local thrift store and a handful of listings in the evenings. As you gain confidence you can scale up or keep it happily small.

If you enjoy the thrill of the hunt, love giving good quality items a second life and like the idea of building a little pot of extra money for treats, holidays or bills, it is absolutely worth trying.

For more ideas on boosting your income, have a look at my post on money hacks that can save you thousands. Then pick one niche, choose one platform and experiment with your first few flips to see if reselling thrift store finds is a good fit for you.

Pin to save:

Pin
Like this post? Share or Pin it!
MessengerPinterestWhatsApp