|

Christmas Buffet Menu Ideas: 3 Complete Menus for a Crowd

Pin
Pinterest Hidden Image

If you’ve already saved a dozen Christmas recipes and still don’t know what to serve together, start with the kind of party you’re hosting. A drop-in party calls for food people can eat with one hand. A family lunch is easier with one hot main and sides you can make ahead. And if everyone’s coming for dinner, a ham buffet gives you the full Christmas meal without having to plate it.

Each Christmas buffet menu below gives you a complete spread for 12 or 24, plus a plan for what to do the day before and what to leave until party day.

Which Christmas buffet menu should you make?

Choose this buffetBest forWhat to plan around
Finger-food buffetA drop-in party near dinnertimeTwo substantial bites and plenty guests can eat standing up
Make-ahead buffetA family lunch or casual supperOne hot main and sides you can finish ahead
Hot Christmas dinner buffetA full meal with everyone eating around the same timeOven space and a final reheating plan

The amounts below are starting points for a mixed group eating a meal. For each dish, the first amount serves 12 and the second serves 24. The quantities are for food ready to serve unless the item specifies a package or bone-in weight. When you pick your recipes, check their yields against the amounts below before you shop.

1. Christmas finger-food buffet for a drop-in party

This post may contain affiliate links.Privacy Policy. Follow us on PINTEREST

Ham and cheese sliders and cranberry meatballs make this spread substantial enough for dinner. Caprese skewers and vegetables with dip bring something fresh to the table, and guests can eat the whole meal from a small plate. If you want to swap in another warm bite or an easy dessert, browse these Christmas finger food ideas.

  • Ham and cheese sliders 18 sliders for 12 / 36 for 24.
  • Cranberry cocktail meatballs 36 small meatballs for 12 / 72 for 24. Put cocktail picks next to the serving dish.
  • Caprese skewers 18 skewers for 12 / 36 for 24.
  • Crunchy vegetables with ranch dip 6 cups of cut vegetables and 1½ cups of dip for 12 / 12 cups of vegetables and 3 cups of dip for 24.
  • Christmas shortbread 24 small cookies for 12 / 48 for 24.
  • Cranberry-lime sparkling punch 3 quarts for 12 / 6 quarts for 24, plus water on the side.

The day before: Bake the shortbread, make the meatball sauce, and wash and cut the vegetables. Chill the punch base and keep the sparkling water separate. For extra dishes you can prep in advance, see these make-ahead appetizers.

On party day: Assemble the skewers and sliders. Warm the meatballs while the sliders bake, add the sparkling water to the punch just before serving, and bring out the skewers and dip in small batches.

If most guests have already eaten, make fewer sliders and meatballs. For a party specifically on December 24, this Christmas Eve grazing buffet has more ideas for guests arriving at different times.

Recipes for the Finger-Food Buffet

These recipes from food bloggers cover every homemade dish on this menu, from the sliders to the punch. Each one links to the creator’s original post, so check the yield against the amounts above before you shop.

Party Ham and Cheese Sliders

Photo credit: Chew Out Loud
Buttery, cheesy ham and cheese sliders that the creator says can be prepared ahead of time. Pop the tray in the oven as guests start to arrive.
Read More

Sweet and Tangy Cranberry Meatballs

Photo credit: The Forked Spoon
Tender meatballs in a sweet and tangy cranberry sauce, made in the slow cooker. Leave them on the warm setting with a pot of cocktail picks beside them.
Read More

Caprese Sticks

Photo credit: Chef Denise
Mozzarella, tomato and basil on a stick, ready in about 15 minutes. They add a fresh red-and-green bite to a table full of warm food.
Read More

Ranch Dip

Photo credit: Natasha's Kitchen
A thick, creamy ranch dip that is ready in under five minutes and holds up well for dipping. Set the bowl in the middle of the vegetable platter so guests can help themselves.
Read More

Christmas Shortbread Cookies

Photo credit: A Cedar Spoon
Rich, buttery shortbread dressed up for the holidays. Shortbread is sturdy, so you can bake it ahead and pile it onto a platter on party day.
Read More

Cranberry Lime Christmas Punch

Photo credit: Dinner at the Zoo
Pomegranate-cranberry juice, limeade and lime sparkling water with cranberries and lime slices floating on top. It is alcohol-free, so it works for everyone at a family-friendly party.
Read More

2. Make-ahead Christmas buffet for a family gathering

A baked pasta main gives you a generous family meal with just one oven dish to think about at a time. A crisp green bean salad and a bright slaw go well with the rich baked ziti, and the dessert is ready in the fridge when you need it. For a different side, these Christmas salad recipes include slaws and other salads that hold up on a buffet.

  • Baked ziti with sausage One deep 9-by-13-inch pan that yields 12 main-dish portions / two pans that yield 24 total. Check the recipe yield since pan depth varies.
  • Lemon green bean salad 6 cups for 12 / 12 cups for 24.
  • Apple-cranberry cabbage slaw 6 cups for 12 / 12 cups for 24.
  • Bakery rolls 12 rolls for 12 / 24 for 24.
  • Gingerbread cheesecake cups 12 individual cups for 12 / 24 for 24.
  • Apple cider with orange slices 3 quarts for 12 / 6 quarts for 24.

The day before: Assemble the ziti if your recipe has make-ahead instructions. Make the cheesecake cups, prep the green beans, and shred the cabbage. Keep the dressings separate and save slicing the apples for party day.

On party day: Allow the time your recipe specifies for baking the chilled ziti. While it’s in the oven, slice the apples, toss both salads, and set out the rolls and cider. If you’re baking two pans, check they fit on your racks before you commit to using one oven.

If guests ask what they can bring, hand off the rolls, drinks, or dessert. If you are also cooking a big sit-down meal this season, my make-ahead Christmas dinner guide shows what to prep and when.

Recipes for the Make-Ahead Buffet

These recipes from food bloggers cover every homemade dish on this menu, from the baked ziti to the cider. Each one links to the creator’s original post, so check the yield and any make-ahead notes before you plan your day.

Baked Ziti with Sausage

Photo credit: Little Nonni
A hearty baked pasta with Italian sausage and a cheesy topping. It bakes and serves from one dish, so the oven only has one job.
Read More

Lemon Green Beans

Photo credit: Cooking For My Soul
Bright, zesty green beans with a fresh lemon finish that take 20 minutes or less to make. Their crunch and tang balance the rich, cheesy baked ziti.
Read More

Festive Cranberry Apple Coleslaw

Photo credit: Little Nomads Recipes
A colorful cranberry and apple coleslaw made with holidays and potlucks in mind. Its crunch is a welcome contrast to the rich, cheesy pasta.
Read More

Mini Gingerbread Cheesecakes

Photo credit: Easy Made Dishes
Little spiced cheesecakes that come ready-portioned, so there is no slicing at the buffet. Guests can pick one up straight from the dessert counter.
Read More

Easy Slow Cooker Apple Cider

Photo credit: One Sweet Appetite
Apple cider simmered in the slow cooker with spices and orange slices, then kept on the warm setting. Leave a ladle in the pot and guests can serve themselves all afternoon.
Read More

3. Hot Christmas dinner buffet for a crowd

Build dinner around maple-Dijon-glazed ham, creamy potatoes, and two vegetables. The cranberry relish gives the plate a bright, tart bite, and an apple crisp can go into the oven once dinner is on the table.

  • Maple-Dijon-glazed spiral ham About 7–8 pounds bone-in for 12 / 14–16 pounds total for 24. Two smaller hams may be easier to fit and serve for a bigger group.
  • Slow-cooker mashed potatoes 9 cups for 12 / 18 cups for 24. Check your slow cooker’s capacity before doubling.
  • Roasted carrots 6 cups for 12 / 12 cups for 24.
  • Green beans with lemon butter 6 cups for 12 / 12 cups for 24.
  • Cranberry-orange relish 1½ cups for 12 / 3 cups for 24.
  • Apple crisp with vanilla ice cream 12 servings and 1 quart of ice cream for 12 / 24 servings and 2 quarts for 24.
  • Sparkling cranberry spritz 3 quarts for 12 / 6 quarts for 24, plus water on the side.

The day before: Make the relish and ham glaze, trim the green beans, peel and cut the carrots, and make the crisp topping. Check the ham package directions and work backward from serving time.

On party day: Plan the oven around the ham. Use the slow cooker for the potatoes and the stovetop for the beans. Roast the carrots when the ham comes out if the dishes need different oven temperatures, and bake the crisp while guests eat dinner.

Recipes for the Hot Christmas Dinner Buffet

These recipes from food bloggers cover every dish on this menu, from the glazed ham to the drink. Each one links to the creator’s original post, so check the yield and timings against your oven plan before you shop.

Maple Glazed Ham

Photo credit: A Farmgirl's Kitchen
A bone-in spiral ham brushed with a sticky glaze of maple syrup, brown sugar, Dijon, orange juice and warm spices. It makes a centerpiece that needs nothing more than a carving knife on the buffet.
Read More

Crockpot Mashed Potatoes

Photo credit: Well Plated
Rich, creamy mashed potatoes made in the slow cooker, with the creator’s notes for making them up to a day ahead. They keep the oven free for the ham.
Read More

Honey Glazed Carrots

Photo credit: Downshiftology
Carrots roasted in a sweet and savory honey glaze until caramelized. You can peel and chop them the day before, then glaze and roast once the ham comes out.
Read More

Lemon Butter Green Beans

Photo credit: Budget Bytes
Fresh green beans finished with butter, lemon zest and lemon juice for a bright side. They cook quickly on the stovetop, which is handy when the oven is full.
Read More

Cranberry Orange Relish

Photo credit: I Heart Eating
A no-cook, three-ingredient relish that takes about five minutes and can be made ahead. Its sweet-tart flavor cuts through the rich ham and potatoes.
Read More

Apple Crisp for a Crowd

Photo credit: Baked by Rachel
An easy apple crisp sized for a crowd, with all the comfort of apple pie and none of the pastry. Serve it warm with scoops of vanilla ice cream.
Read More

Sparkling Cranberry Mocktail

Photo credit: But First We Brunch
Cranberry, apple and rosemary topped up with bubbles for a festive drink that everyone can enjoy. Set it out on the drinks counter next to the water.
Read More

How to set up a buffet table that’s easy to serve from

Put plates first, then the main dish, sides, and sauces. Set drinks and dessert on a separate counter so guests coming back for a refill can skip the food line. For 24 guests, put out a second serving utensil for the most popular dishes and keep spare platters handy for refills.

Set out the empty platters and serving utensils the night before, with a slip of paper naming the dish that goes in each. If you want the table to feel festive using what you already have, see these simple Christmas table decoration ideas.

Like this post? Share or Pin it!