|

45 Make-Ahead Appetizers for Holiday Parties, Family Gatherings and New Year’s Eve

Pin
Pinterest Hidden Image

Make-ahead appetizers are the reason I actually get to enjoy my own parties. When most of the food is prepped a day or two before, party day is about warming, plating and pouring drinks, not cooking against the clock.

I’ve gathered 45 make-ahead finger foods from food bloggers, and where the creator shares make-ahead notes, I’ve noted what you can do in advance. Every recipe links to the original, so check the creator’s storage notes before you plan your timeline. If you’re cooking a big holiday meal as well, my make-ahead Christmas dinner guide shows what to prep and when.

Festive Parties That Call for Make-Ahead Appetizers

Any party gets easier with a make-ahead menu, but these are the gatherings where it makes the biggest difference.

  • Friendsmas. You’ll want to be on the couch with your friends, not in the kitchen. My Friendsmas food ideas guide shows how to share out the menu.
  • Family reunions and holiday get-togethers. Big crowds mean big batches, so choose recipes that scale up easily and hold well.
  • Office parties and potlucks. Cold appetizers and room-temperature snacks travel well and don’t need the host’s oven.
  • Christmas Eve or New Year’s Day open house. Prep your platters ahead, then refill them as guests come and go. For a December open house, pick a few more bites from these Christmas finger food ideas.
  • New Year’s Eve. Get the work done early and you’ll still have energy left at midnight. Fill out the spread with these New Year’s Eve finger foods.

Cold Make-Ahead Appetizers, Snacks and Sweets

This post may contain affiliate links.Privacy Policy. Follow us on PINTEREST

These need no reheating at all. Make them ahead, keep them chilled or stored airtight, and set them out when guests arrive. They’re ideal when oven space is tight or you’re carrying food to someone else’s home.

Crack Chicken Pinwheels

Photo credit: The Cookin Chicks
Creamy, savory chicken rolled up and sliced into pinwheels. Make them fully ahead, as the creator recommends refrigerating the prepared pinwheels for up to two days before serving.
Read More

Deviled Eggs with 10 Topping Variations

Photo credit: Get Inspired Everyday
A classic deviled egg recipe with ten different toppings, so you can make one big batch and dress it up several ways for a crowd.
Read More

Honey Goat Cheese Balls

Photo credit: A Cedar Spoon
Bite-size goat cheese balls with a sweet touch of honey. Pretty, poppable and lovely on a cheese board.
Read More

Smoked Trout Dip with Lemon and Dill

Photo credit: Peak to Plate
Smoked trout, fresh herbs and a creamy, tangy base. Serve it with crackers or baguette slices.
Read More

Easy Antipasto Skewers

Photo credit: WonkyWonderful
A fun, no-fuss finger food for parties and holidays. Thread a big batch and keep them chilled until guests arrive.
Read More

Marinated Mozzarella Balls

Photo credit: Little Nonni
Mozzarella balls in a flavorful marinade that only gets better with time. Marinate them overnight, then add cocktail picks when you serve.
Read More

Cucumber, Tomato and Feta Phyllo Cups

Photo credit: Country Gardens & Table
Cucumber, tomatoes, roasted red pepper and feta in a honey balsamic dressing, spooned into crisp phyllo cups. Make the filling ahead and assemble at the last minute.
Read More

Southern Deviled Eggs with Relish

Photo credit: Dr. Davinah's Eats
Classic Southern deviled eggs with relish in the filling. Assemble them a day ahead and keep them covered in the fridge until it’s time to serve.
Read More

Mini Cheese Balls

Photo credit: My Rad Kitchen
Cream cheese, bacon and ranch rolled into one-bite cheese balls. All the flavor of a classic cheese ball, with no crowding round the knife.
Read More

Salmon Cream Cheese Spread with Dill

Photo credit: The Lavender Apron
An easy salmon and cream cheese spread made with just four ingredients in about five minutes. Spread it on baguette slices or serve with crackers.
Read More

Spicy Deviled Eggs with Bacon and Jalapeño

Photo credit: Chili Pepper Madness
Deviled eggs kicked up with bacon and jalapeño. A bold twist for guests who like a little heat.
Read More

Roasted Garlic Cashew Cream Dip

Photo credit: Beet of the Wild
A dairy-free roasted garlic cashew cream that doubles as a dip. Serve it with crudités for guests avoiding dairy.
Read More

Mini Cheese Ball Bites

Photo credit: I Heart Naptime
Little individual cheese balls, ready to pick up and pop. An easy appetizer for a crowd.
Read More

Make-Ahead Appetizers to Bake or Reheat on Party Day

These need a little time in the oven or slow cooker before serving, but the hard work is done in advance. Plan your oven time so a tray goes in just as guests arrive, and you’ll have something warm coming out all evening.

Brie Bites with Puff Pastry

Photo credit: The Art of Food and Wine
Baked brie bites in puff pastry with cranberry jam. The creator notes they can be made ahead of time, which makes them a stress-free choice for a busy party day.
Read More

Party Ham and Cheese Sliders

Photo credit: Chew Out Loud
Buttery, cheesy ham and cheese sliders that the creator says can easily be prepared ahead of time. Bake them as guests arrive.
Read More

Slow Cooker BBQ Little Smokies with Root Beer Glaze

Photo credit: Kim Schob
Little smokies in a sweet, tangy root beer BBQ glaze. Cook them ahead, reheat them in the slow cooker and set out toothpicks.
Read More

Bacon Wrapped Chorizo Stuffed Dates

Photo credit: Get Inspired Everyday
Medjool dates stuffed with a creamy chorizo filling and wrapped in bacon. The creator includes two make-ahead options to make entertaining easier.
Read More

Sun-Dried Tomato and Spinach Puff Pastry Bites

Photo credit: Flavorful Eats
Flaky puff pastry bites filled with spinach, sun-dried tomatoes and cheese. Assemble and chill them ahead, then bake when you need them.
Read More

Crispy Italian Arancini

Photo credit: Cooking Gorgeous
Rice balls made with leftover risotto and a melted mozzarella center. You can make them ahead and fry them just before serving.
Read More

Baked Maryland Crab Cakes

Photo credit: Chef Denise
No-fry crab cakes served with a classic remoulade. Make them appetizer-size, bake them in advance and reheat before serving.
Read More

Cheddar Cheese Sausage Balls

Photo credit: Little Black Skillet
Sausage balls made from scratch with sharp Cheddar and breakfast sausage, no Bisquick needed. Like a sausage and cheese biscuit in one bite.
Read More

Savory Pecan Praline Cream Cheese Dip

Photo credit: Vegetarian South
Seasoned cream cheese with a warm brown sugar pecan topping. The creator describes it as a quick, make-ahead Southern party appetizer.
Read More

Grape Jelly Meatballs

Photo credit: Chili Pepper Madness
The classic sweet and tangy party meatball. Keep them warm in a slow cooker and set out toothpicks.
Read More

Mini Holiday Meat Pies

Photo credit: Little Nomads Recipes
Spiced beef in golden shortcrust pastry, baked in a muffin tin. Kid-friendly and, as the creator notes, simple to make ahead.
Read More

Sourdough Discard Pretzel Bites

Photo credit: This Jess Cooks
Soft pretzel bites made with sourdough discard. Bake them ahead and warm them through just before serving.
Read More

Mild Buffalo Chicken Dip

Photo credit: Feels Like Home
An easy five-ingredient buffalo chicken dip that’s perfect for taking to a potluck or party. Serve it warm with chips and celery.
Read More

Prosciutto Wrapped Dates

Photo credit: Next Level Baker
Dates filled with creamy goat cheese and wrapped in prosciutto. Stuff and wrap them ahead, keep them in the fridge, then bake until crispy before serving.
Read More

Chicken Sausage Rolls with Puff Pastry

Photo credit: Bites with Bri
Flaky puff pastry wrapped around a flavorful chicken sausage filling. A crowd-pleaser for parties and family gatherings.
Read More

Sweet and Sour Meatballs

Photo credit: Chew Out Loud
Saucy sweet and sour meatballs made for toothpicks. A warm, filling bite for a crowd.
Read More

Slow Cooker Marinated Olives

Photo credit: Flavorful Eats
A mix of olives warmed with fresh garlic, herbs and lemon peel. An easy, hands-off appetizer for entertaining.
Read More

Bourekas Pinukim

Photo credit: At the Immigrant's Table
Flaky, savory stuffed pastries that make easy comfort food. A little different from the usual party pastries.
Read More

Maryland Crab Cakes

Photo credit: The Forked Spoon
Classic Maryland crab cakes made with lump crab meat. Shape them small for an appetizer platter.
Read More

Air Fryer Buffalo Turkey Meatballs

Photo credit: The Delicious Spoon
Turkey meatballs tossed in buffalo hot sauce, made with just a few ingredients. A quick and easy party appetizer.
Read More

Baked Ham and Cheese Pinwheels

Photo credit: On My Kids Plate
Ham and cheese rolled up and baked into golden pinwheels. A kid-friendly bite for a family gathering.
Read More

Paleo Bacon Wrapped Dates

Photo credit: Mary's Whole Life
Sweet dates wrapped in bacon and made paleo-friendly. A simple, crowd-pleasing bite for guests with dietary needs.
Read More

Chicken and Potato Cutlets

Photo credit: Spoons of Flavor
Crispy on the outside and tender inside. Make them small for a filling finger food.
Read More

Make-Ahead Snack Mixes, Crackers and Sweet Bites

Snack mixes, crackers and sweet bites are some of the easiest things to get done early. Most keep well in an airtight container, so make them first and you’ll have bowls to fill and dippers ready for the dips above with no last-minute work.

Easy Crockpot Chex Mix

Photo credit: The Frugal Girls
Chex, Melba snacks, pretzels, Cheez-Its and cashews tossed with ranch seasoning and Parmesan, then cooked in the slow cooker. A big batch for snacking all season.
Read More

4-Ingredient Southern Cheese Straws

Photo credit: Little Black Skillet
Crunchy cheese straws with a hint of spice. Add them to a charcuterie board or give them as holiday gifts.
Read More

Maple Roasted Nuts

Photo credit: The Lavender Apron
Nuts roasted with pure maple syrup in the oven or air fryer. A simple sweet snack for a bowl by the drinks.
Read More

Homemade Baked Pita Chips

Photo credit: Seasons in the Kitchen
Crisp pita chips baked with olive oil and seasoning. Perfect for scooping up the dips in this list.
Read More

Healthy Candied Cranberries

Photo credit: Whole New Mom
Festive low-carb candied cranberries made with a no-simmer method. Serve them with drinks or scatter them over desserts.
Read More

Ranch Dill Oyster Crackers

Photo credit: The Chaotic Table
Oyster crackers baked with butter, ranch seasoning and dill until crisp. An easy, snackable bowl for the drinks table.
Read More

Cinnamon Sugar Pretzels

Photo credit: Semi Homemade Kitchen
Pretzels baked with cinnamon and sugar until crisp, using pantry staples. A simple sweet-and-salty snack.
Read More

Almond Flour Chia Seed Crackers

Photo credit: Beet of the Wild
Crispy, crunchy crackers made with just four simple ingredients and no eggs or milk. A great base for the cheese and dip platter.
Read More

No-Bake Date Balls

Photo credit: Unicorns in the Kitchen
Sweet date balls that take about 15 minutes to roll. Make them in advance and keep them chilled until you’re ready to serve.
Read More

How to Plan a Make-Ahead Appetizer Timeline

A simple countdown keeps the last-minute jobs small. Here’s the order I like to work in.

  • Two or three days before. Make snack mixes, date balls and anything else that keeps well in an airtight container or the fridge.
  • The day before. Assemble pinwheels and deviled eggs, marinate cheese, and prep the fillings for anything you’ll bake.
  • Party morning. Thread skewers, set out platters and serving spoons, and label each dish.
  • An hour before guests arrive. Switch on the slow cooker and bake the first tray of warm bites.
  • Follow the recipe. Each creator’s storage notes are the best guide to how far ahead you can safely go.

More Holiday Hosting Ideas

For a full menu, my complete Christmas buffet menus show what to serve together for a crowd, and my free party planning checklist walks you through every step of the party.

Here’s to a holiday season where you get to enjoy your own parties!

Like this post? Share or Pin it!